Pennsylvania’s Superior Court has devoted a number of opinions to the difference between a “mere encounters” and “investigative detentions;” particularly in the context of car stops. Courts have long recognized that a car stop is a seizure within the meaning of the constitution. As discussed in a recent post on this blog, all occupants of a vehicle are detained pending an officer’s investigation into the motor vehicle code or criminal code violation the officer reasonable suspected was afoot. However, what happens once a traffic ticket or warning is written? Is the coercive nature of the interaction over? Or are all the occupants of the vehicle free to leave? Most importantly, is it ok for a police officer to keep you on the side of the road after they gave you a ticket? In a recent case handled by our firm, both the trial court and the Superior Court held that an officer needs reasonable suspicion of criminal activity to detain a driver on the side of the road after a traffic stop. In this case, a State Trooper further detained a driver, after investigating his unlawful tinting, because he believed the driver was engaged in drug-smuggling. The Trooper questioned the driver for a few minutes and then asked for consent to search the car. The driver provided consent and the Trooper discovered cocaine during the ensuing search. According to the Trooper, he suspected criminal activity because he observed the following: 1) excessive window tint in violation of Pennsylvania’s regulations, 2) three cellphones, two air fresheners, one Red Bull and one 20 oz bottle of Mountain Dew; 3) the fact that the vehicle, although properly registered, was registered to a third-party from a suburb of Philadelphia; 4) the driver’s nervousness as evidence through a quivering voice and shaking hands; 5) the driver’s two prior drug-related arrests. The trial court granted the driver’s motion to suppress held that there was no reasonable basis to infer drug-smuggling from the list of innocent information gathered by the Trooper. Noone disputed that the Trooper personally had a subjective suspicion that the defendant was smuggling drugs and although Noone disputed that the suspicion was in fact correct (because drugs were recovered in the car), nonetheless, this evidence was suppressed because the suspicion simply wasn’t reasonable. This decision prohibited the Commonwealth from introducing any of the drug evidence found during the search because the driver only gave permission to search during an unconstitutional detention. The Commonwealth appealed that decision to the Superior Court. After reading written briefs filed by both parties and hearing an oral argument in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, the Superior Court affirmed the suppression. Read the opinion! Commonwealth v Simon
What makes a suspicion reasonable?
On Behalf of Hark and Hark | Mar 23, 2011 | Firm News |
Categories
- Blog (36)
- Criminal Defense (48)
- Drug Crimes (31)
- Dui (20)
- Federal Crimes (13)
- Firm News (306)
- Injuries (6)
- Medical Nursing (59)
- Pennsylvania Criminal Law (34)
- Philadelphia Criminal Justice Updates (13)
- Professional License Application (37)
- Professional License Issues (193)
- Professional Misconduct (9)
- Substance Abuse (1)
- Uncategorized (2)
- USMLE and ECFMG (3)
Archives
- October 2024 (2)
- September 2024 (1)
- August 2024 (3)
- July 2024 (3)
- June 2024 (2)
- May 2024 (3)
- April 2024 (4)
- March 2024 (2)
- February 2024 (3)
- January 2024 (2)
- December 2023 (3)
- November 2023 (3)
- October 2023 (4)
- September 2023 (1)
- August 2023 (2)
- July 2023 (3)
- June 2023 (3)
- May 2023 (2)
- April 2023 (3)
- March 2023 (3)
- February 2023 (3)
- January 2023 (2)
- December 2022 (4)
- November 2022 (3)
- October 2022 (3)
- September 2022 (2)
- August 2022 (4)
- July 2022 (4)
- June 2022 (5)
- May 2022 (2)
- April 2022 (2)
- March 2022 (3)
- February 2022 (4)
- January 2022 (2)
- December 2021 (3)
- November 2021 (2)
- October 2021 (3)
- September 2021 (2)
- August 2021 (4)
- July 2021 (3)
- June 2021 (3)
- May 2021 (3)
- April 2021 (2)
- March 2021 (3)
- February 2021 (3)
- January 2021 (4)
- December 2020 (4)
- November 2020 (5)
- October 2020 (3)
- September 2020 (8)
- July 2020 (3)
- June 2020 (5)
- May 2020 (2)
- April 2020 (8)
- March 2020 (9)
- February 2020 (7)
- January 2020 (4)
- December 2019 (8)
- November 2019 (5)
- October 2019 (6)
- September 2019 (1)
- August 2019 (3)
- July 2019 (1)
- June 2019 (3)
- May 2019 (5)
- April 2019 (6)
- March 2019 (4)
- February 2019 (5)
- January 2019 (7)
- December 2018 (10)
- November 2018 (8)
- October 2018 (7)
- September 2018 (5)
- August 2018 (6)
- July 2018 (3)
- June 2018 (8)
- May 2018 (5)
- April 2018 (1)
- March 2018 (2)
- February 2018 (2)
- January 2018 (4)
- December 2017 (2)
- November 2017 (5)
- October 2017 (3)
- September 2017 (2)
- August 2017 (4)
- July 2017 (3)
- June 2017 (6)
- May 2017 (2)
- April 2017 (3)
- March 2017 (2)
- February 2017 (1)
- January 2017 (5)
- November 2016 (3)
- October 2016 (5)
- September 2016 (2)
- August 2016 (5)
- July 2016 (1)
- June 2016 (1)
- May 2016 (1)
- April 2016 (2)
- March 2016 (3)
- February 2016 (4)
- January 2016 (2)
- November 2015 (3)
- October 2015 (2)
- September 2015 (3)
- August 2015 (1)
- July 2015 (3)
- June 2015 (3)
- May 2015 (2)
- April 2015 (4)
- March 2015 (3)
- February 2015 (1)
- January 2015 (2)
- December 2014 (1)
- November 2014 (3)
- October 2014 (1)
- September 2014 (2)
- August 2014 (2)
- July 2014 (2)
- June 2014 (5)
- May 2014 (3)
- April 2014 (5)
- March 2014 (2)
- February 2014 (1)
- January 2014 (2)
- December 2013 (3)
- November 2013 (5)
- October 2013 (4)
- September 2013 (2)
- July 2013 (3)
- June 2013 (3)
- May 2013 (5)
- April 2013 (2)
- February 2013 (1)
- January 2013 (1)
- December 2012 (2)
- November 2012 (1)
- October 2012 (7)
- September 2012 (2)
- August 2012 (1)
- July 2012 (1)
- June 2012 (1)
- May 2012 (1)
- April 2012 (1)
- February 2012 (3)
- January 2012 (2)
- September 2011 (1)
- August 2011 (1)
- June 2011 (2)
- May 2011 (1)
- April 2011 (2)
- March 2011 (2)
- February 2011 (1)
- January 2011 (1)
- December 2010 (3)
- November 2010 (2)
- October 2010 (1)
- September 2010 (1)
- August 2010 (3)